Blood River by Tim Butcher is the bestselling travel writing book of recent years and with good reason. When he wrote it Mr Butcher was the Johannesburg correspondent of the ‘Daily Telegraph’ and while covering events in Africa he became interested in the journey of the British/American explorer H.M. Stanley across the centre of Africa, discovering what became the Belgium colony of the Congo.
Butcher wondered if the journey could be repeated again today and he started to make inquiries as to its feasibility. The Congo today has almost become a byword for a failed state, a country beset by lawlessness, with large areas controlled by warlords whose bands rob and murder at will. Many of the people Butcher contacted thought he was mad to contemplate travelling in the Congo and even the ‘Telegraph’ washed their hands of him, but after a lot of effort he was ready to start his journey.
Being a journalist the book is very well written, compelling reading, the best travel book I’ve read in years (but that’s not saying much). Butcher interweaves his own story with Stanley’s, and with the history of the Congo from it’s discovery, through the colonial period and onto how it became the wreck of a state it is today. Very hard and dangerous travelling, as most of the country’s infrastructure has collapsed, and he was very lucky to get as far as he did. In the end though he had to resort to flying, this is a country where waiting months for transport to move is not uncommon.
After reading the book I was lucky enough to see Mr Butcher give a lecture about this journey at the Royal Geographical Society in March 2009, where he gave an overview of his trip illustrated with pictures, which gave further insights into the situation in the Congo.
He empathized one of the themes in his book, that the world has allowed the Congo, a vast country the size of Europe and containing millions of people to go backwards. During the colonial period the country was connected to the modern world but due to corruption and war the country is now no more developed than when Stanley passed through in the 1890’s. Nature is encroaching again; there is a wonderful scene in the book where Butcher and his motorbike driver stop in the jungle for a rest. Walking around Butcher knocks his toe against something solid, so he drags the vegetation off to discover a rail. He then realizes that in colonial times this jungle track had trains and railway carriages running through it, now it had been completely reclaimed by the forest.
In the book Mr Butcher was very unsympathetic to the Belgian Colonists and it’s true they operated a form of apartheid and people couldn’t move freely without permission. However in his talk he acknowledged that they did build the only infrastructure the country’s ever had and most crucially they provided the one thing that is now so sorely lacking, the key to development, to everything in fact – the rule of law. He reminded us that the killing goes on, much of it tribal with thousands being killed every month and that this gets almost no coverage in the West.
However there are now new colonialists in the Congo – the Chinese. Of the very few goods that make it into the interior, nearly all of the them are made in China, and that has killed off all the indigenous trade. In their hunger for raw materials the Chinese have done deals (given bribes) to what remains of the functioning government to exploit the country’s mineral wealth. Mr Butcher pointed out that the Chinese are building infrastructure again, but the roads and railways only go to places where the Chinese have an interest, the mines, there is nothing for the people.There’s no doubt that all the machines and material will be imported because the Congo has nothing; but that was the case in Colonial times. In fact the Chinese don’t only bring in their own engineers and managers they also bring in their own labourers, so the Congolese don’t even see the benefit of a few menial jobs. There are thought to be around a million Chinese now working in Africa, taking the jobs from people who only have one asset – their manual labour.
During questions at the end of the lecture Mr Butcher was asked why he thought African countries did not progress after colonialism, while countries in Asia powered ahead. His opinion was that African cannot tolerate success. If an African wins something, or succeeds in business, his neighbours and often his own family will try to take it off him or some how bring him down. He felt that until Africans can look at success as a positive thing, the continent will not progress.
When asked why he thought such a dangerous journey had been successful Butcher felt it was because he had spent a lot of time choosing good guides, they had been the key. He mentioned that he had been contacted by the parents of a traveller who had been in West Africa trying to replicate the journey of Mungo Park. This man has disappeared without trace and even though his parents have been out to Niger distributing leaflets and posters his body will probably never be found. It’s most likely he was the victim of the people he was travelling with. Such is Africa.
I first visited Vietnam in 1995 and was very impressed by the people and the country. Everyone seemed to be working to rebuild after the years in the wilderness and the tourist industry was growing fast. Companies like Sind Cafe were thinking about the new visitors wanted and doing their best to provide it.
What a contrast to how things were on my recent trip there. The country is firmly on the tourist map and its now a sizeable industry, providing jobs for lots of people. This doesn’t mean that things are better than they were, on the contrary, tourists are now taken for granted, they are just people from whom money must be extracted.On one hand you have the bike and tuk tuk boys from whom the hassle is continuous. They will follow you up the street working on the assumption that if they ask you nine times if you want to rent a motorbike, perhaps the tenth time, you might say yes. On the other hand most of the cities where tourists go there are streets filled with ‘travel agencies’. Many of these copy the names of their more successful rivals – like Sind Cafe but nearly all of them are staffed by young men and women who really don’t care. They were all children when I first visited, and for them tourists have always been there, and in growing numbers – so they’ve never had to try very hard. Their grasp of English is limited to trying to work out what you want, then telling you the price – which is often made up on the spot. Forget getting any kind of description of what you might actually be getting for your money, that’s beyond them. You’d be very unwise to buy a ticket from a travel agency in Vietnam as I found mark ups of 100% +, is fairly normal.
This kind of complacency is also evident in most of the hotels as well, after all you’re dragging them away from their TV watching and mobile phone fiddling. In a country where most of the tourists speak English, you’d have thought that people who deal with in order to sell them things, might be working on improving their language skills. I came across a couple of girls who tapped me for a free English lesson, but otherwise most people were content to get by with – This is the price, give me the money.
It goes across the board, so expect rental bikes which are rusted pieces of junk, or internet ‘cafes’ where the staff have no idea about computers or how to deliver the services (like burning a CD) that posters on the walls say they provide. Another punter will come through the door – so why bother?
I’m now in Laos, where in the most part people are more interested in looking after tourist needs, as out in the countryside cooking a few banana pancakes is a lot easier than working in a paddy field. However, I’ve now arrived in Luang Prabang, which again I first saw in 1995 when travelers were quite rare, due to the security issues that existed then. Of course things are very different now, the country is safe and firmly on the tourist map and facilities in the lovely town of Luang Prabang have expanded accordingly. All to the good. Except that the people here behave very much like the Vietnamese, as no trip to Laos is complete without visiting Lunag Prabang, so a continual stream of tourists is assured. So here we are again with the indifferent service, the below average food and the ‘can you go away and stop bothering me’ attitude.
At the beginning of this trip I passed through Thailand which also has its pockets of hassle, like Kho Shan Road and on some of the islands. But the Thais have been in the tourist industry a lot longer, and they know that tourists can disappear if things are not to their liking. Most people want a holiday, and not to be asked ‘you buy something in my shop’, every time they walk down the street. Right now, with the global downturn, numbers are down, hotels are in trouble and the Thai Government is handing out free visas in order to get those figures up. They know that they can’t take tourists for granted.
So maybe when the numbers dip in Vietnam the people in the travel industry will work out they are in a global market – and they have to raise their game if they want people to keep on coming. I myself won’t be back.
Leave a Comment
Posted in Travel comments | Tags: blogsherpa, Travel comments, Travellers, vietnam